Notary Bulletin Special Report: New Standards For Mortgage Signings By Michael Lewis on October 29, 2013 in Signing Professionals (From the November 2013 issue of The National Notary magazine) The collapse of the housing market and numerous other crises have caused the government to significantly increase its scrutiny of the mortgage industry. This challenging new environment is forcing lenders, title companies, signing services and others in the mortgage origination world to take a hard look at how business is done. Of all the people involved in originating mortgages, Notary Signing Agents received little attention. That is changing. In order to comply with federal mandates, lenders now recognize that the tens of thousands of Signing Agents who represent them at the signing table need to be better qualified. As a result, leading lenders and title companies gathered to create the first set of recommended best-practice standards for Notaries handling loan signings. These standards are called the Certified Signing Specialist Standards and form the basis of a new designation for signing professionals: the Certified Signing Specialist. That is a Notary who has met all of the elements of the standards. The publication of the Standards is among the most significant developments to hit the loan-signing profession in years, and it will help you meet the needs of nearly every firm in the real estate finance industry. In turn, you will be eligible for more jobs that will help you thrive in the current market. A special committee called the Signing Professionals Workgroup (SPW) comprised of executives from major lenders and title companies, developed the Standards. The National Notary Association was asked to serve as an expert advisor. In that role, we helped the Workgroup understand the scope of your responsibilities and the challenges you face. “Signing Agents often have had to meet widely varying requirements and qualifications from one company to another,” said NNA President and CEO Thomas Heymann. “The Standards and new Certified Signing Specialist designation are intended to provide a set of qualifications and practices for everyone. Ultimately, they should help reduce the number of different requirements Notaries face to keep getting loan-signing assignments.” “The banks and title companies depend on the professionalism and competency of the person at the signing table,” Cristy Ward, Chief Strategy Officer of Mortgage Connect and a Workgroup participant, said in a recent interview. “Upholding the recommended Standards assures a consistent closing experience for all of the parties involved in the transaction.” In fact, a key focus for lenders and regulators alike is improving the borrower’s experience. In that context, even though you generally don’t work directly for lenders, you represent them with every loan you handle. Speaking during an industry panel discussion at NNA 2013 Conference last June (see the July 2013 issue of The National Notary), Donna Davidson, Vice President of Vendor Management for Citibank, put it succinctly: “Most of the time, you’re the only face our borrowers are going to see.” The workgroup coined the Certified Signing Specialist designation for two reasons. First, the concept of a Certified Signing Specialist recognizes the fact that you possess qualifications and expertise that those outside your field do not. Second, lenders prefer not to call you “agents” because that term carries a specific legal meaning that implies you have the authority to act on their behalf as though they were personally present. What Are The Standards? The Standards are comprised of five elements: The Certified Signing Specialist Code of Conduct Standardized signing script Annual examination Annual background screening Notary errors and omissions insurance The heart of the Standards is the Certified Signing Specialist Code of Conduct. The Code of Conduct is organized into 10 Guiding Principles encompassing more than 100 individual Standards of Practice. They cover everything from protecting signers’ privacy and acting in a professional manner to not providing unauthorized advice or services and reporting illegal or suspicious activity. To obtain and maintain the Certified Signing Specialist designation, you will be required to sign an acknowledgment stating that you will abide by the Code of Conduct’s Standards of Practice. The Standards also include a uniform Signing Script that outlines how a signing should be conducted and how you should answer questions about each document. It also indicates when to direct the signer to contact the lender and when you should call the title company representative. The Script was included in the Standards in large part to create a high-quality customer experience at the signing table from signing to signing. As a Certified Signing Specialist, you will be expected to use the Script for all signings. You also will be expected to pass an annual exam, which will be created by the Signing Professionals Workgroup — with a score of at least 80 percent — covering the Signing Script as well as knowledge of loan documents and best practices outlined in the Code of Conduct. The annual exam is in keeping with the requirements for other professionals working in the real estate finance industry. Mortgage originators, for example, are required under federal law to complete at least eight hours of continuing education each year. In addition, the SPW will continue revising the Standards as regulations and market conditions change. Annual testing will be necessary to ensure that Signing Specialists keep abreast of any updates. Background screenings have become a common expectation for Signing Agents, but not all screenings are the same, and an annual screening is new. For background screenings to be acceptable under the Standards, they must include searches in state, local and federal records and follow a point system assigned to specific offenses for calculating the pass/fail result. In opting for an annual screening, the SPW noted that Signing Specialists routinely handle documents containing sensitive consumer financial information and are invited into borrowers’ homes. “At the end of the day, it’s our job to protect the consumer, and to provide the best closing experience possible,” Ward said at the NNA 2013 industry panel. The annual background screening also protects you because it helps keep people out of the profession who should not be handling the sensitive consumer information contained in loan documents or entering peoples’ homes. Without the background screenings, unscrupulous individuals could enter the profession and misuse their trusted position, and just a few widely publicized cases could tarnish all of you. The final Standard requires $25,000 Notary errors and omissions insurance for Certified Signing Specialists. While lenders and title companies commonly required NSAs to maintain Notary errors and omissions insurance, the amounts varied. During Workgroup deliberations, participants debated how much E&O insurance Signing Specialists should carry, with some arguing for a minimum coverage of at least $100,000. Some lenders even require $500,000. Because Notary E&O insurance only covers notarial errors, the workgroup decided that $25,000 in coverage was adequate. The Standards will be rolled out in the coming months as the SPW establishes an application and vendor review process to license qualified companies to offer certification services. In addition, the SPW is creating procedures for monitoring and auditing vendors to make sure their programs comply with the Standards. This is vital because vendors will be creating a new generation of highly-skilled and qualified Certified Signing Specialists. Why Now? Perhaps the most significant single development leading to the formation of the SPW and the publishing of Certified Signing Specialist Standards was the passage in 2010 of the federal Dodd-Frank Act and its creation of a new federal agency — the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) — with sweeping powers to regulate all types of financial companies. Shortly after its inception in July 2011, the CFPB set up a consumer complaint system that received more than 85,000 mortgage-related reports from disgruntled borrowers through June of this year. Spurred by the flood of consumer reaction, the agency has issued thousands of pages of new regulations, recommendations and guidance. It also has brought numerous enforcement actions costing lenders and other financial companies more than $750 million in refunds and penalties. And it has implemented an active audit program for the companies it regulates. All of this work is focusing on protecting the consumer and pressing the financial industry to provide a much better and more consistent customer experience regardless of the bank or title company involved. The publication in April 2012 of a CFPB Bulletin under the heading, “Service Providers,” prompted executives at several of the top major lenders and title underwriters to start addressing what happens at the signing table. The two-and-a-half-page Bulletin noted that financial institutions cannot shift the burden of complying with federal law to the service providers they hire, but are ultimately responsible for ensuring that their service providers follow the law. A service provider that fails to uphold the law or has “weak internal controls” can harm consumers and create potential liabilities for themselves and their contracting firms. “Lenders are being held accountable for the actions of their outside service providers, such as title companies and whoever they hire — including Signing Specialists,” Heymann said. The CFPB Bulletin told lenders to verify that their service providers complied with federal law and maintained “appropriate training and oversight of employees or agents.” In addition, lenders are expected to establish ongoing monitoring programs, and put in place enforceable consequences for providers who fell short and failed to quickly address their shortcomings. As a result, these expectations have been incorporated in the contracts between banks and title companies, which in turn affect signing services and Signing Specialists. Failing to abide by the terms of the contacts can have serious consequences for title companies and lenders. “We can lose literally millions of dollars because of a poor signing,” Ward said during the NNA 2013 session. “So we have taken a lot of precautions to make sure we are looking at the quality of the loan docs that are coming back to us.” That is why the SPW is paying attention to what happens at the signing table. The importance of the Standards to the mortgage origination industry cannot be underestimated, Heymann noted. “Every Notary who becomes a Certified Signing Specialist and every company that relies on them is operating under the same rules and knows exactly what to expect at the signing table,” he said. “Only good things will happen by everybody working together.” Michael Lewis is Managing Editor at the National Notary Association. For more information about the Certified Signing Specialist Standards, visit NationalNotary.org/Standardsor email firstname.lastname@example.org. For questions regarding your specific situation or account, email email@example.com or call toll free 855-762-5415. Related Articles: Introducing The Signing Professionals Workgroup The Certified Signing Specialist Standards The Transition Process: From Signing Agents To Certified Signing Specialists Email Share 3 Comments Add your commentJim Benton01 Jan 2015If you have any input into the formulation of the qualifications for this certification please require that it requires in depth knowledge of the mortgage documents and the mortgage process. There are way too many DRONES conducting closings today. I hear all too often of how the "Notaries" don't know what the documents represent simply shove them in front of the borrowers and tell them "sign here". Many mistakes are made. Many borrowers are left confused at times because the loan officer didn't do their job well. I spent over 25 years in the mortgage industry doing everything from origination, processing and underwriting to a company VP and a company owner. Believe me something needs to SERIOUSLY CHANGE. "Notaries" should NOT be conducting closings. Only those well educated in the mortgage process & real estate process should be allowed to close a loan or sale purchase transaction. The Signing Agent is the last person the borrowers have contact with in the lending transaction. It is for many the largest financial transaction they will ever enter in to. They should receive professional, world class service. Also it is important that Signing Agents be paid well for delivering this service. Too many signing agencies assign work to the Notary who will work for the least amount of money. Elevating the Signing Agents job to that of a "Professional" would weed out many of those who are simply unfit to be conducting mortgage closings. It should take a serious investment in one's education to become and remain a Certified Signing Agent. Jim Benton Former Mortgage Lender, Real Estate Broker, Certified Residential Appraiser and currently a full time SIGNING AGENT (TITLE INSURANCE PRODUCER) in Maryland.firstname.lastname@example.org Jan 2015I agree that the Signing Agents should be paid well, especially when there are so many pages of documents need be notarized plus the travel. I must say, even though Signing Agent is the last person to contact with the lending transaction that the Signing Agent should be more familiar with the loan documents and not just tell them "sign here'. I too, spent more than 25 years in mortgage and construction industry doing from construction processing, cash management, and commercial processingRose T Covarrubias04 Nov 2015I agree wholly with Jim. Many times you get a text, email or a call and they want you to do a signing . 1. to accept the signing for $75 and if is a large package with about 200. Thats 200 x 2 - 400. they don't have any notion what it takes to print and do these signings. you have to: 1. Call the borrower and confirm appointment. 2. call, text email or go into website to confirm appointment (all this is good) 3. wait for documents to come to you so that you can print docs 4. prepare the docs (get familiar with docs) so that you can present the package 5. drive to location 6. present the docs to borrower answer questions for them (only those that you are suppose to answer to) many times no one has gone thru the terms and cost with them. 7. do the signing and acknowledgement?jurat whatever is needed, journal.(now its a signature for every notarization. Go thru docs to make sure everything was done correctly. 8. Call text email or website to close closing 9 go thru all the docs make sure nothing was left undone.. Not to mention all the paper and toner to print the docs...And they want us to do it for $75.00. They'll say we have to get an approval over the amount of $75.00. But what is being done is that they will call someone else to see if they will bite for the $75.00 Another thing that bothers me is that you get the order from the signing company they put down instructions for the signing (this is where all the instructions should be) but no when you get the package there are sometimes 2-3 pages of instructions. Some repeating what the signing order has plus much more. Why can't the title/escrow (whomever) give the instructions to the signing Company, so when you get the order you read everything in one place. This is how some errors might occur, I think.. Signings I think would have alot less mistakes if all instructions came with our Signing Orders.. Well these are my thoughts..Leave a Comment Required * Name * Email *(for verfication purposes only) Comment * Enter the text shown in this image *(text is case sensitive)All comments are reviewed and if approved, will display.