The duties Notaries perform are strictly regulated by state law. Answering the wrong kinds of questions from signers can get you in serious legal and financial trouble.
Below are three risky questions signers commonly ask Notaries, why these questions can be dangerous, and how the National Notary Association’s Hotline Team recommends responding. The three risky questions include:
- “Can't you just bend the rules to help me out?”
- “Can you help me prepare this document?”
- “Can you accept a copy or picture of my ID?”
Risky Question 1: “Can’t you just bend the rules to help me out?”
When signers need notarizations, it’s often urgent. If signers have a problem getting to you, or there’s an issue with their ID, they often ask you to ignore proper procedure or bend the rules, including variations such as:
- “I forgot my ID. Can’t you just notarize my signature without it?”
- “My kid is sick, and I can’t make it to your office. Can’t I just send the document for you to stamp and pick it up later?”
- “This is an important client. I know the law says you need to ask for his driver’s license, but I don’t want to embarrass him, so would you just notarize without it?”
The Risk: Failing to follow the correct procedure is an invitation to lose your Notary commission.
Failing to follow required Notary procedures — such as personal appearance or proper identification—violates state Notary law. This can result in commission suspension or revocation, civil liability, and increased risk of fraud.
If you don’t require a signer to personally appear for the notarization, ignore the requirements for satisfactory evidence of identity, or agree to any improper Notary requests, you are breaking the law and opening the document to potential fraud. If a dishonest signer can commit fraud thanks to your negligence, you not only risk your commission but you could be held liable for any damages a victim suffers as a result.
The Recommended Response: A Notary should never bend or break the rules. Politely explain that state law requires you to follow specific procedures and that you cannot proceed if those requirements are not met. If the signer refuses, decline the notarization.
Risky Question 2: “Can you help me prepare this document?”
Signers often need important legal or business documents notarized but aren’t sure how to complete them, so they may turn to you for help:
- “Help me out. Can you tell me what information I need to fill in here?”
- “Can you prepare a power of attorney document for me?”
- “What kind of notarization do I need for this type of document?”
The Risk: Notaries who are not attorneys are prohibited from engaging in the unauthorized practice of law, which includes preparing documents, completing legal forms, or selecting the type of notarization for a signer. Violations may result in civil penalties or criminal charges, depending on state law.
Unfortunately, many well-intentioned Notaries don’t realize that answering questions about a document, preparing a document or simply choosing the type of notarization constitutes a violation if the Notary is not a qualified attorney, and can result in civil or criminal liability.
The Recommended Response: If you are asked to help prepare or complete document or choose the type of notarization needed, and you are not an attorney, you should decline and explain that you are not allowed to provide legal advice. If you are asked to choose a notarization for them, you may describe the different types of notarizations available and let the signer decide, the signer can contact the document-issuing agency or receiving agency for instructions. Another option is for the signer to speak with a qualified attorney.
Risky Question 3: “Can you accept a copy or picture of my ID?”
While every state’s rules are different when it comes to identifying signers, all without exception agree that a signer must present an original ID to the Notary. You should be careful if a signer asks you one of the following questions:
- “I’ve got a photocopy of my driver’s license. Can you accept that instead?”
- “I don’t have my ID with me, but here’s a picture of it on my mobile phone, OK?”
The Risk: It’s never a good idea to accept a photocopy or image in lieu of an actual ID. Without having the original ID, you have no way of knowing if the copy or image has been altered or changed. Also, a copy lacks the security features, such as holograms or raised text, that you can use to help verify an ID is genuine — increasing the chance that a dishonest signer can get away with fraud without you realizing it.
The Recommended Response: Don’t accept a photocopy or photo in place of an actual identification card. If the signer doesn’t have an ID, don’t proceed with the notarization but invite the signer to return with their ID in hand.
Notaries are often placed in uncomfortable situations by well-meaning signers, but following the law is non-negotiable. By understanding which signer questions are risky — and knowing how to respond — you can protect your commission, avoid legal liability, and maintain the integrity of every notarization you perform.
David Thun is the Editorial Manager at the National Notary Association.
Additional Resources:
The Notary Public Code Of Professional Responsibility
NNA Hotline