Updated 5-30-23. No one likes to say “no” to a customer. But it’s almost certain that at some point you will have to turn down a signer’s notarization request. And that’s not a bad thing.
Why? Two reasons. First, refusing an unethical or illegal request is part of your duties. Notaries have a responsibility to follow the law and should never agree to any act that violates the basic rules of notarization, or that would enable document fraud or other crimes.
Second, saying no when justified means that you are carrying out your duties carefully and responsibly, and by recording the refusal in your Notary journal you will have documented your exercise of reasonable care. While you should never refuse a request without good reason, you should never act as a “yes man” who gives in to any demand.
When refusing a notarization, there are three important questions to ask yourself:
- Do I have a good reason for turning down the request?
- What do I need to record in the journal entry if I refuse a notarization?
- How do I best protect myself if I have to appear in court due to my refusal?
Here are the answers to each of these questions.
Have good reason to say ‘No’
Notaries should not refuse a request arbitrarily. Always make sure that you have good cause. You cannot turn down a request simply because of a gut feeling, a nagging suspicion or because you simply “don’t like the look” of the signer.
Some reasons for refusing are clear cut: Say, for example, the signer asks you to notarize his absent wife’s signature. Because the signer’s request would violate your state’s Notary laws, you must refuse. Another example would be if a signer asked you to falsify information in the Notary certificate, such as including a wrong date of notarization. If your signer lacks satisfactory proof of identity that complies with your state’s laws, you would also have to say no.
Other reasons are less clear cut and require you to make a judgment call, typically involving something questionable about a signer’s behavior or appearance, or about whether the signer is acting voluntarily (without being unduly influenced or coerced) and is mentally competent to sign. In these situations, you should ask questions to see if the signer allays your concerns or continues to behave in a manner that indicates you must stop the process.
A good example would be if a signer were to show up wearing a large hat and sunglasses, making it difficult to compare her appearance to the photo on her driver’s license. If the signer refuses to take off her glasses and hat or if her appearance does not match the ID photo, it may be time to stop the notarization.
Or suppose an elderly signer is accompanied by a younger relative. The signer doesn’t respond to your questions, but the relative insists the signer is willing and demands that you proceed. Unless you can speak directly with the signer without interference to make sure he understands what he is signing and is doing so willingly, you should stop things right there.
Record your reason in your journal
Your next step is to document in your journal entry why you refused the notarization. Situations where you refuse a notarization are one of the prime reasons to keep a journal. Should your decision be questioned later, having a clear record showing why you acted is one of the strongest defenses you can have against accusations of negligence or misconduct.
For every notarization, always record the essential Notary information and signatures from the signer in your journal before performing the requested act. That way, if it turns out you have to stop the notarization and the signer leaves unexpectedly, you still have the full information to document the refusal and — if you suspect a crime — alert the police.
Be sure to clearly record why you refused the notarization and provide as many details as you can that support your reasons.
Noting something such as, “I refused because I didn’t like the way the signer looked at me,” doesn’t provide a clear reason.
But if you can say, “The signer’s hair color, age and height didn’t match his ID photo, and he acted nervously,” that’s a plausible indication that something suspicious is going on.
In order to properly refuse a notarization, you should have one or more reasons to do so that can be objectively articulated in your journal. In other words, you should be able to explain why you are refusing to notarize. If you can't explain it, then you don't have a sufficient basis to do it. And, you should take as much space in your journal as you need to do this clearly and thoroughly — because it may be very important in the future for you to have a good record of this event.
Saying ‘No’ for the right reasons can help protect you in case of a formal complaint
Refusing a notarization for the right reasons may become the most important notarial act you will ever carry out — provided you have properly recorded the information in your journal. The reason is if you are later sued or accused of misconduct, your journal will be admissible evidence in any trial or disciplinary proceeding. Your entire journal could be scrutinized by the judge, hearing officer, jury, or discipline panel. So, a refused notarization thoroughly noted in your journal will be very helpful even in a case involving a different notarization, because the properly recorded refusal shows your habit of exercising reasonable care and diligence.
Judges and juries often gauge a Notary’s honesty and professionalism based on not just one notarization or journal entry, but the overall evidence in the journal. A Notary who keeps a poor journal record is not likely to be deemed trustworthy or professional. A Notary who keeps a diligent record of past notarizations — and is willing to refuse improper requests — is far more likely to receive a favorable decision.
I once testified in a multimillion-dollar trial in which a Notary was charged with negligence and fraud in the performance of three specific notarizations. Over a period of several years, the Notary had recorded more than 1,200 notarizations, including one refusal to notarize. I testified about how the journal and refusal showed that this Notary had acted thoroughly and conscientiously for years. Some of the jurors were smiling and nodding as I explained what the journal showed. The verdict went in favor of the Notary.
The law’s reasonable care standard is the Notary’s best friend. You will not be held liable if you show that you have exercised reasonable care in conducting the notarization. And a detailed journal is the best way to prove reasonable care. So, always, always, always keep a detailed journal record of every act — especially if you have to say no.
Michael Closen is Professor Emeritus at the John Marshall Law School in Chicago, Illinois. A respected consultant on model Notary statutes and legislation, Closen served on the drafting committees for The Notary Public Code of Professional Responsibility and various editions of the Model Notary Act, and recently authored the book, Professor Closen’s Notary Best Practices: Expert's Guide to Notarization of Documents.
Related Articles:
5 scammers Notaries need to watch out for
Additional Resources:
NNA Hotline